[HacktionLab] Debate about attribution and aggregation - visionontv example

[m3shrom]

On 25/02/2011 11:36, m3shrom wrote:
> Hi there,
> 
> I wanted to talk about Attribution and Aggregation. I think that this is
> an interesting debate with the new possibilities of Cross Posting and
> aggregation coming up.
> 
> Put simply - can we come up with some informal guidelines to encouraging
> cross posting and aggregation without feeling like people have 'nicked
> our content'. 	
> 
> --an example
> 
> I think it's worth looking out for examples of this to guage how we
> feel. This is one example, sorry if this feels like I'm pointing the
> finger a bit here, I kind of am but just to work out if we can improve
> the situation. It could be anyone.
> 
> Mule has posted a video on YouTube and embeded it in their site.
> Vision on TV take the youtube feed and aggregate it into their site.
> You get to see it here -
> http://visionon.tv/web/grassroots/;jsessionid=7E18215E7E9D6E7ACC929FA6239E5BCB

http://grassroots.mirocommunity.org/video/2450/the-big-society
sorry the above link didn't work

> Attribution -
> There is a link "view video in original page" - which takes you to
> YouTube - but this link doesn't work
> 
> Also you can click on the authour listed as manchestermule1 which takes
> you to this page -
> http://grassroots.mirocommunity.org/author/165
> Which again has no link to the Mule's website.
> 
> --//
> Clearly we can do better than this. Maybe we could work out some
> friendly guidelines, which we can send people to, so that people can
> think about these issues and be clear about how they want their work to
> be reused.
> 
> --///
> I know that this came up with the ***ymedia Aggregator survey that me
> and Mara did. This is out of date but it does communicate something.
> 
> 1) How should posts appear when linked to from the “aggregated
> newswire” of an ‘UK IMC aggregated frontpage’?
> 
> 12 	links to original posts, title only 	
> 6 	link with abstract and link to original post, title and abstract only 	
> 2 	link to page on the uk aggregated site with full content (as much as
> technically possible) and link to original post
> 
> _______________________________________________
> HacktionLab mailing list
> HacktionLab at lists.psand.net
> http://lists.psand.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/hacktionlab


-- 
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.14 (Darwin)
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=qPvf